MM2 Rare values
All 40 rare items in Murder Mystery 2 with their trading value and demand, highest first. Updated November 16, 2026.
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
Cane KnifeRare4/10 | 525 |
DungeonRare2/10 | 115▼7% |
DarkKnifeRare3/10 | 65▼4% |
Silent Night KnifeRare1.5/10 | 50 |
Makeshift KnifeRare2/10 | 35 |
Zombified (2022)Rare2/10 | 301 list |
Starry GunRare2/10 | 221 list |
SwirlRare2/10 | 20 |
Watcher GunRare2/10 | 201 list |
Silent Night GunRare2/10 | 13 |
Magma GunRare2/10 | 13 |
SnowflakesRare2/10 | 121 list |
GhostfireRare2/10 | 12 |
Floral KnifeRare2/10 | 10 |
Cowboy (Retro)Rare2/10 | 101 list |
Laser (Retro)Rare2/10 | 101 list |
Phaser (Retro)Rare2/10 | 101 list |
Prince (Retro)Rare2/10 | 101 list |
Ghastly GunRare2/10 | 71 list |
Aurora Knife (2019)Rare2/10 | 71 list |
Toxic KnifeRare2/10 | 51 list |
Wraith KnifeRare2/10 | 51 list |
Icicles GunRare2/10 | 31 list |
JackRare2/10 | 31 list |
Snakebite KnifeRare2/10 | 31 list |
Vampire Gun (2018)Rare2/10 | 31 list |
Magma (2017)Rare1/10 | 31 list |
Candy Swirl GunRare2/10 | 21 list |
SunRare2/10 | 21 list |
Bats (2016)Rare1/10 | 21 list |
Green MarbleRare1/10 | 21 list |
Orange MarbleRare1/10 | 21 list |
Toxic GunRare1/10 | 21 list |
DarkgunRare2/10 | 11 list |
Gingerbread (2017)Rare1/10 | 11 list |
MonsterRare1/10 | 11 list |
Aurora Gun (2019)Rare1/10 | 11 list |
Candy Swirl KnifeRare1/10 | 11 list |
Snakebite GunRare1/10 | 11 list |
Vampire Knife (2018)Rare1/10 | 11 list |
Values are the median of the community value lists that include each item; items marked "1 list" come from a single list. How we set values
Other MM2 groups
AncientUniqueChromaGodlyVintageLegendaryUncommonCommonPetSet
Questions
What is the most valuable rare item in MM2?
On our list it is Cane Knife at 525, followed by Dungeon (115) and DarkKnife (65), as of November 16, 2026.
How many rare items are on the list?
40. Half of them are worth 6 or less.